How to Check Whether an AI Image Edit Kept the Composition

In the first image, the stone path bends just before it reaches two white cottages. In the watercolor, most of the paving has turned into patches of tan and gray. The bend is still there.
That was the part we cared about. Individual stones can disappear and the path still takes you through the same scene. Move the bend or send the path to a different spot and the view starts to feel unfamiliar. We used that distinction to decide what the model could repaint and what we wanted it to leave in place.
The source is a generated photographic reference from the project’s image-editing tests.
The saved edit from Nano Banana 2.1.
Decide what you’ll check before you run the edit
Start with a reference that has a few features you could point to without zooming in. In the coastal image, the big ones are the bend in the path, the cottages above the inlet, and the tree framing the right edge. The tree’s individual leaves are a different matter. You can paint those loosely and still recognize the place.
Write those details down before you see the result. It’s easier to spot a shifted roof if you’ve already decided where it needs to be. If the image is meant to match the composition in a series, put the features that anchor that composition in your notes. If it’s a looser interpretation, decide which parts can move.
To try this edit, use the first image as your only reference. Start with the original framing if your editor offers a choice. Select Nano Banana 2.1 if you have access to the same model. These were the two instructions used for the saved result.
What should change?
Render the landscape in soft watercolor with loose brushwork, transparent washes and visible paper grain.
What should stay the same?
Keep the same path, houses, coast, tree positions and viewpoint.
If your editor takes one prompt, put the two instructions on separate lines. It helps to keep them separate in your own notes either way. When something drifts, you can change the instruction about the scene while leaving the instruction about the paint alone.
Check the whole view, then look close
Put the two images side by side at the same display width. Start small enough to see the whole frame. At that size, it’s easier to notice that a tree has shifted or a building has become much larger. You can look at the brush marks once the layout makes sense.
| Check | What the saved result shows | When to take another pass |
|---|---|---|
| Path | It still enters from below and bends toward the cottages. | The bend straightens or the path goes somewhere else. |
| Cottages and inlet | Both cottages are visible in front of the water. | The houses merge or a roof moves into a different part of the view. |
| Right edge | The tree still frames the right side. | The tree moves inward enough to cover a house or blocks the view of the inlet. |
At full size, the first place to look for the watercolor effect is the sky. The blue thins out near the top, where you can see some paper-like grain. The bushes look like patches of paint, and most of the roof tiles are gone. There’s still a clear edge between the nearer roof and the wall. That edge helps it read as a cottage among the looser shapes.
A pixel-by-pixel comparison would flag changes in the sky that are part of the watercolor effect. For this edit, check the layout at the landmarks in the table. A few leaves or paving stones can move and the scene still holds together.
Keep the next run easy to compare
Suppose the sky looks right and the path has straightened. Start from the original image again. Leave the watercolor instruction in place and add one sentence to the second prompt. For this scene, you could try “Keep the curved foreground path and the point where it passes below the two cottages.”
If the landmarks are in the right places and the image still looks like a photo, change the style instruction instead. Pick one part of the frame. Try asking for broader washes in the sky, or for the nearest roof tiles to become a few larger marks. That gives you a particular spot to check when the next result comes back.
Both are suggestions for a new run. The images here show the saved result from the original two prompts. For your comparison, keep the reference, model, and framing fixed where you can. Save the two instructions with each result. When two files look similar, the saved prompts tell you which line was different.
One final check is worth doing if the edit is going into a layout. Preview the crop you’ll actually use. A shallow banner can cut out the bend in the path even when the full image kept it. Try the same crop on the source and output before deciding you need another render.
The images and prompts come from a saved Image 2 Image example. The source and edited image were generated, and AI drafted the article.
